Written by: David Cossalter If you’re considering making a personal injury claim, there’s a good chance one question is weighing on your mind more than any other: will I have to go to court?
It’s one of the most common concerns we hear, and it’s completely understandable. The thought of formal court proceedings, cross-examination, and speaking in a public hearing can feel daunting. Particularly when you’re already dealing with an injury, financial pressure, and the disruption it has caused to your everyday life.
At GMP Law, the vast majority of our personal injury claims are resolved through negotiation and settlement, without ever reaching a courtroom. But what does that process actually involve? Why are most claims settled before trial? And are there circumstances where taking a matter to court may be the right option?
In this guide, we’ll explain what you can expect from the personal injury claims process, why settlement is often preferred, and when proceeding to court may be genuinely necessary.
Why most claims settle rather than go to trial
Starting a claim does not mean you are committing yourself to a trial. In most personal injury matters, the goal is to resolve the claim without the need for a court hearing.
Court proceedings can be expensive, time-consuming, and uncertain for everyone involved, including the insurer. For that reason, insurers will often consider settlement once the evidence is clear enough to properly assess the claim.
Why insurers generally prefer to settle
- Litigation is costly. Taking a matter to trial involves significant legal and administrative costs.
- Trials are uncertain. Even where an insurer considers its position strong, a trial leaves the outcome in the hands of a judge.
- Prolonged disputes take time and resources. Keeping a claim open means continued legal work, evidence gathering and assessment.
- Settlement provides certainty. Once the evidence allows both sides to properly assess liability and damages, resolving the claim can make commercial sense rather than continuing to incur the costs and risks of litigation.
What settlement can mean for you
- A faster resolution. A negotiated outcome can often be reached before a matter is ready for trial.
- Less stress. You may avoid the experience of giving evidence and being cross-examined in court.
- Greater certainty. You know the outcome you have agreed to, rather than leaving the result to a judge.
- Lower legal costs. Preparing a matter for trial can be one of the most significant stages of a claim in terms of time and cost.
Get a free claim check
Settlement can happen at any stage
Settlement is an ongoing process. As the claim develops and more evidence becomes available, both sides can better understand the strength of their respective positions and assess whether the matter can be resolved without going to trial.
This does not mean settlement will happen quickly or that every claim will settle. Negotiations can take time, and achieving a fair outcome requires careful preparation and a clear understanding of the evidence supporting your claim.
Your legal team will continue to assess the claim as it progresses and advise you on any settlement offers, including whether an offer fairly reflects your legal entitlements and the evidence available.
Key takeaway
Starting a claim does not mean it will end in court. The legal process gives you a pathway to pursue your claim while preserving opportunities to resolve it along the way. Most of our claims at GMP Law settle before court, allowing our clients to achieve a resolution without having to go through the stress, cost and uncertainty of a trial.
What actually happens in a settlement negotiation
Knowing what happens after you open a claim can make the process feel far less daunting. Starting a claim with GMP Law does not mean you are heading straight to court. In most cases, there is a structured process of investigation, information exchange and negotiation that takes place first.
While every claim is different, most matters broadly follow these stages:
1. Initial assessment and investigation
Once you engage a lawyer, the first step is to understand what happened, how you’ve been affected, and what your claim may be worth. This usually involves gathering and reviewing evidence such as medical records, witness accounts, accident reports, employment records, and other documents relevant to your claim.
This early preparation is important because the stronger the evidence, the stronger your position when it comes time to negotiate.
2. Notification to the insurer
Your lawyer will formally notify the relevant insurer that you are making a claim. Depending on the circumstances, this may be a CTP insurer, public liability insurer, or workers’ compensation insurer.
The insurer will then begin its own assessment of the claim, including considering the circumstances of the incident, liability, and the extent of your injuries and losses.
3. Exchange of information
As the claim progresses, both sides gather and exchange the information needed to properly assess it. This may include medical reports, evidence of lost income, treatment records, and expert opinions where required.
The aim is to build a clear picture of both what happened and what the injury has cost you, so that the claim can be properly valued.
Want to learn more about documenting your loss?
4. Settlement negotiation
Once there is enough evidence to assess the claim, your lawyer will generally make a settlement demand on your behalf. The insurer will then respond, usually with an offer.
Negotiations can involve several rounds of offers and counteroffers as both sides work towards an outcome that reflects the evidence and the value of the claim. Depending on the matter, negotiations may also take place through a formal settlement conference or mediation.
5. Resolution
If an agreement is reached, the matter is formally settled, and you receive your compensation in accordance with the agreed terms.
This is where the vast majority of claims conclude. Court is not the automatic next step when you start a claim. Rather, it is generally only necessary where the parties cannot reach a reasonable agreement. For example, because liability remains genuinely disputed or the insurer’s offer does not fairly reflect the value of the claim.
Legal insight
Starting a claim begins a legal process, and by initiating that process, you place yourself in the best position to establish, protect and pursue the entitlements to which you may be legally entitled.
When going to court may be in your best interests
While most personal injury claims resolve through negotiation, there are circumstances where taking steps towards a court hearing may be the right decision. The important point is that being prepared to go to court can strengthen your position, even if the matter ultimately settles before a hearing.
1. When liability is seriously disputed
If the insurer refuses to accept responsibility and the available evidence cannot resolve the dispute through negotiation, a court may ultimately be required to determine who is legally responsible.
2. When the settlement offer doesn't reflect your actual losses
If the insurer is undervaluing your claim and negotiations are not producing a fair outcome, being prepared to proceed to court can demonstrate that you are serious about pursuing your legal entitlements. In some cases, the prospect of litigation is what encourages the insurer to reconsider its position.
3. When the claim raises an important legal issue
Some claims involve a genuine legal question that cannot be resolved through negotiation alone. In these circumstances, a judicial determination may be necessary to resolve the issue and establish how the law applies to your circumstances.
Legal precedent
In Salman v Hornsby Shire Council, we pursued the matter through the Court of Appeal because the case raised an important question about council responsibility for playground safety. The outcome established a precedent about how councils must account for the way people actually use playgrounds, helping strengthen safety obligations for communities beyond Ms Salman herself.
What "No Win, No Fee" means for your risk
One of the biggest concerns people have about starting a claim is what it might cost them if things do not go as expected.
At GMP Law, we work on a No Win, No Fee arrangement. The basic principle is that you do not pay legal fees as the matter progresses. If your claim is unsuccessful, you will not have to pay those legal fees for the work undertaken on your behalf. If you receive compensation, our professional fees are paid from the amount recovered, in accordance with your cost agreement.
The important thing is to understand exactly what your cost agreement covers. In addition to legal fees, there are disbursements associated with pursuing a claim, such as medical and expert reports, which should be clearly explained to you before you proceed.
When you speak with a lawyer, make sure you ask the right questions about fees, disbursements, and what you could be required to pay throughout the claim, so you understand the financial arrangements before you decide to proceed.
What starting a claim actually commits you to
Deciding to make a claim is a significant step, but it is not a decision to take your matter all the way to trial. At the outset, your lawyer’s focus is on understanding what happened, gathering the evidence, and establishing whether you have a claim worth pursuing.
Starting a claim means: | Starting a claim does not mean: |
|
|
As the claim progresses, your lawyer will keep you informed about your options and the likely costs, risks and benefits of each step. And at every stage, you remain in control of key decisions, particularly whether to accept a settlement offer.
Making an informed decision
The decision to make a personal injury claim can feel daunting, particularly when you are unsure what the process will involve. But you do not need to have every stage mapped out before you take the first step.
A good legal assessment should give you a clearer understanding of your position, the evidence needed to support your claim, the potential value of your entitlements, the costs involved, and the options available to you as the matter progresses.
The purpose of getting legal advice is not simply to decide whether you will go to court. It is to understand your rights and make informed decisions about how best to pursue them.
