Written by: Richele Nelsen As parents, we trust childcare centres to provide a safe, nurturing environment where our little ones can learn, play, and grow. However, when that trust is broken through negligence or misconduct, the impact can be devastating – not just for the child, but for the entire family.
If you’re reading this guide, you may be grappling with concerns about your child’s safety or seeking answers about a troubling incident. Know that you’re not alone, and there are pathways to justice and protection for your child.
Understanding childcare negligence in Australia
Childcare negligence is more than just a legal term – it represents a fundamental breach of the sacred trust between parents and caregivers. While we understand that children naturally experience bumps and scrapes as part of growing up, there’s a clear distinction between normal childhood accidents and incidents that occur due to negligent care.
Recent trends in Australian childcare facilities paint a concerning picture.
The Australian Children’s Education & Care Quality Authority (ACECQA) reported in its December 2023 safety review of Early Childhood Education and Care settings that there has been a significant rise in breaches related to insufficient supervision and the failure to safeguard children from harm and hazards. Between 2016-17 and 2022-23, cases of inadequate supervision of children tripled, while incidents involving the failure to protect children from harm and hazards more than doubled.
In response to these concerns, several early learning educators shared their experiences with ABC for an investigation in March 2024, shedding light on critical issues regarding staff ratios and safety in childcare centres. Key points raised include:
- Educators are frequently forced to work out of ratio, with some centres exploiting the “under roof ratio” to justify staff shortages.
- The “under roof” rule, which allows staffing levels in different rooms to balance each other out, is being misused to cut costs, leading to situations where a single staff member is responsible for up to 16 children.
- Staff roles are sometimes miscounted, such as including the chef in staff ratios or requiring one educator to care for five babies at once.
- Educators are also burdened with paperwork and cleaning duties, leaving them with less time and capacity to supervise children properly.
These reports underscore the urgent need for stricter enforcement of staff ratio regulations to ensure the safety and well-being of children in early childhood education settings.
Find out how much you can claim today
What is duty of care in childcare?
The concept of duty of care in a childcare setting goes far beyond simple supervision. It encompasses a comprehensive obligation to protect children’s physical, emotional, and developmental well-being.
Legal obligations include:
1. Physical safety measures
- Regular safety audits of all equipment and facilities
- Proper storage of dangerous materials
- Adequate fencing and security measures
2. Emotional and developmental care
- Age-appropriate activities and supervision
- Protection from bullying or peer abuse
- Support for children with special needs
- Appropriate behavioural management strategies
3. Health and medical considerations
- Proper administration of prescribed medications
- Appropriate food handling and allergy awareness
- First aid readiness and emergency response protocols
- Regular staff training in health and safety procedures.
Example scenario: The importance of proper protocols
Let’s examine a situation that illustrates how proper duty of care should work.
Four-year-old Emma has a severe peanut allergy, clearly documented in her enrollment forms. One afternoon, she shows signs of an allergic reaction. In a properly managed centre, the response should include:
- Immediate recognition of symptoms by trained staff
- Swift implementation of Emma’s action plan
- Prompt communication with parents
- Detailed incident documentation
- Review of how the exposure occurred
- Implementation of preventative measures.
However, in a centre failing its duty of care, the scenario might involve:
- Delayed recognition of symptoms due to inadequate training
- Confusion about the location of Emma’s EpiPen
- Poor communication with parents
- Incomplete or missing incident reports
- No follow-up investigation or preventative measures
Key warning signs of childcare negligence
Recognising the signs of negligence early can prevent serious harm and help protect not just your child, but others in the facility as well.
Let’s explore these warning signs in detail.
Physical environment red flags
The physical environment of a childcare centre can tell you much about its commitment to child safety.
Watch for:
1. Unsecured access points that could allow children to wander into unsafe areas
- Gates that don’t latch properly or can be easily opened by children
- Unfenced or poorly fenced outdoor play areas
- Unlocked storage areas containing cleaning supplies or equipment
2. Playground and equipment issues
Broken equipment that hasn’t been repaired or properly cordoned off
Playground surfaces that aren’t adequately cushioned
Age-inappropriate equipment accessible to younger children
Splintered or rusted play structures
3. Indoor hazards
- Exposed electrical outlets or loose wiring
- Unsecured furniture that could tip over
- Cleaning supplied or medications stored within children’s reach
- Broken or damaged toys with sharp edges or small parts.
Behavioural and physical warning signs
Changes in a child’s behaviour or well-being are often the most telling signs that something is wrong. Although deeply unsettling, these changes can indicate that a child may be at risk of sexual abuse, as children are particularly vulnerable to such harm.
Parents should be alert to:
a) Sudden behavioural changes
- Unusual fear of being changed or cleaned
- New anxiety about going to the bathroom
- Regression in toilet training
- Unexplained fear of particular staff members of areas
- Sleep disturbances or nightmares
- Unusual sexual knowledge or behaviour inappropriate for their age
- Sudden changes in eating habits
b) Physical signs of concern
- Unexplained bruising or marks, particularly in private areas
- Difficulty walking or sitting
- Torn or stained underclothing
- Signs of physical restraint on wrists or arms
- Recurring urinary tract infections.
Supervision and staff-related concerns
Quality supervision is the cornerstone of safe childcare.
Be alert to:
Staffing patterns
- High turnover rates that prevent children from forming stable relationships
- Staff members who appear overwhelmed or distracted
- Multiple incidents occurring during particular staff members’ shifts
Training and qualification issues
- Staff unable to explain safety protocols when asked
- Lack of visible first aid certificates or required qualifications
- Inconsistent responses to emergencies or injuries.
Real-world example: Kyneton daycare
In a recent case, a Victorian childcare centre was found to have employed a worker who allegedly falsified their qualifications. This incident underscores a common assumption among parents that all staff members are properly qualified. It also reveals significant gaps in the centre’s hiring process, specifically in verifying the credentials of staff before employment.
Contact us for confidential, free advice.
Legal framework and regulations for childcare centres
Australia’s childcare regulations have evolved significantly in response to incidents and changing understanding of child safety needs. Currently, centres must comply with the following.
National Quality Framework (NQF) requirements
The National Quality Framework (NQF) sets out essential standards for early childhood education and care services across Australia, aiming to ensure the safety, well-being, and development of children.
Key NQF requirements include:
| Staff-to-child ratios | Specific ratios are established based on the age groups of children to ensure adequate supervision and individual attention. These ratios are designed to promote high-quality care and a safe learning environment. |
| Minimum qualification requirements | The NQF mandates that all staff members meet minimum qualification standards, ensuring that educators possess the necessary knowledge and skills to provide quality care and education. |
| Regular quality assessments and ratings | Services undergo regular assessments by the Australian Children’s Education & Care Quality Authority (ACECQA), which assigns ratings based on compliance with the NQF. These assessments help maintain high standards and identify areas for improvement. |
| Documented policies and procedures | Services must have clear and documented policies and procedures in place covering a range of areas, including child protection, health and safety, and staff management, to ensure consistent and transparent practices. |
| Incident reporting protocols | The NQF outlines protocols for reporting and responding to incidents, including those related to child safety and well-being. These protocols ensure that any concerns are promptly addressed and that services are held accountable for maintaining a safe environment for children. |
Together, these requirements work to create a framework that supports continuous improvement in early childhood education and care services, promoting the best outcomes for children.
State-specific regulations
Each state and territory has additional requirements, but gaps in the system remain concerning:
1. Enforcement challenges
Limited resources for regular inspections
Varying interpretation of standards between jurisdictions
Delayed response to compliance issues
2. Systemic issues
- Inadequate protection for whistleblowers
- Insufficient transparency in reporting
- Complex complaint investigation processes.
Common types of childcare negligence claims
Understanding the various types of negligence claims can help parents identify potential issues before they escalate.
1.Supervision failures
The most common type of negligence involves inadequate supervision.
Examples include:
- Children leading designated areas unnoticed
- A child walking out of the centre unnoticed during transition time
- Multiple children being supervised by too few staff members
- Staff distracted by phone use or personal conversations
- Playground incidents
- Children using equipment inappropriate for their age
- Rough play going unnoticed
- Children accessing unsafe areas.
2. Environmental hazards
These claims often involve:
- Structural issues
- Damaged flooring causing trips and falls
- Unstable equipment
- Poor maintenance of outdoor areas
- Safety violations
- Toxic materials left accessible
- Broken toys with sharp edges
- Unsecured heavy furniture.
3. Staff-related issues
Problems with staff behaviour or training can lead to:
- Improper child handling
- Rough physical handling during routine care
- Inappropriate discipline methods
- Failure to follow safe sleep practices
- Medical response failures
- Delayed response to injuries
- Incorrect first aid application
- Failure to recognise serious symptoms.
4. Serious violations of trust
While most childcare workers are dedicated professionals, serious violations of trust can occur.
These include:
- Criminal behaviour
- Failure to properly screen staff
- Inadequate supervision that allows for inappropriate contact
- Failure to report suspicious behaviour
- Inadequate policies to prevent isolated one-on-one situations
- Systemic failures
- Lack of proper background-checking procedures
- Insufficient monitoring of isolated areas
- Poor staff training on recognising signs of abuse
- Inadequate protocols for personal care routines.
